Overview

Language models can generate a great deal of text. Getting them to generate a genuinely varied collection of ideas is harder. Ask for a thousand solutions, and you may get a thousand variations on a few familiar approaches.

One prompt, similar directions

1 prompt · 9 responses

Different concepts, more directions

3 concepts · 3 responses each

Start with different themes, then explore within each one. The same number of responses can cover a wider range of ideas. Colors illustrate the idea; this is a diagram, not a measurement.

That matters for automated research. In program search, automation, or feature engineering, a system proposes candidates and tests which ones work. If the candidates keep returning to the same ideas, much of the possible solution space goes unexplored. We want a way to spread those attempts across more of that space before evaluating them.

Our approach is simple: generate a collection of concepts first, then generate responses within each concept. We call this concept-guided prompting. In a recipe-writing experiment, it produced a more varied collection than two simpler prompting strategies. Recipes give us a concrete way to study the idea; whether it improves automated research itself is a question for future experiments.

Concept-Guided Explained

Imagine putting together a recipe book. Instead of repeatedly asking for another recipe, first ask for a set of themes. Each theme gives the model a different starting point, and a small collection of recipes grows from each one. The aim is to vary the broad ideas before filling in their details.

We generated 1,000 recipes with each of three strategies: independent requests with different identifiers, requests that avoid previously generated titles, and our concept-guided approach with 100 themes and ten recipes per theme. All three used the same model, GPT-OSS-120B, with temperature set to zero and top-p to one. This kept the model’s sampling settings fixed while we changed the prompts.

Three ways to ask for something new

Nonce

Ask for a recipe each time, adding a different identifier to the prompt.

Spiced Pumpkin Lentil Soup

Ingredients: - 1 cup red lentils, rinsed - 2 cups pumpkin puree - 1 medium onion, diced - 2 cloves garlic, minced - 1 carrot, grated - 1 celery stalk, diced - 1 tsp ground cumin - 1 tsp smoked paprika - ½ tsp ground coriander - ¼ tsp cayenne pepper (optional) - 4 cups vegetable broth - 1 tbsp olive oil - Salt and black pepper to taste - Fresh cilantro leaves for garnish - 1 tbsp lemon juice Instructions: 1. Heat olive oil in a large pot over medium heat. Add the diced onion, carrot, and celery; sauté until softened, about 5 minutes. 2. Stir in the minced garlic, cumin, smoked paprika, coriander, and cayenne pepper; cook for 1 minute until fragrant. 3. Add the pumpkin puree and red lentils, mixing well to combine. 4. Pour in the vegetable broth, bring the mixture to a boil, then reduce heat to a simmer. 5. Cook, uncovered, for 20‑25 minutes, or until the lentils are tender and the soup has thickened. 6. Season with salt, black pepper, and lemon juice; adjust seasoning to taste. 7. Using an immersion blender, blend the soup until smooth (or leave it chunky if preferred). 8. Ladle the soup into bowls, garnish with fresh cilantro leaves, and serve hot. Nonce: 892b4ae35bdd7edd88f31f658acb885f8a2832ec

Prior titles

Show all earlier titles and ask for a recipe that has not appeared before.

Cinnamon‑Spiced Roasted Carrot and Lentil Soup with Coconut Milk

Ingredients: - 1 lb carrots, peeled and cut into 1‑inch pieces - 1 cup red lentils, rinsed - 1 medium onion, diced - 2 cloves garlic, minced - 1 tbsp fresh ginger, grated - 1 tsp ground cinnamon - ½ tsp ground cumin - ¼ tsp ground coriander - 1 tbsp olive oil - 4 cups vegetable broth - 1 cup coconut milk (full‑fat) - Salt and freshly ground black pepper, to taste - Fresh cilantro leaves, for garnish - 1 tbsp lime juice Instructions: 1. Preheat the oven to 400°F (200°C). Toss the carrot pieces with olive oil, half the cinnamon, and a pinch of salt; spread on a baking sheet and roast for 20‑25 minutes, until caramelized and tender. 2. While the carrots roast, heat a large pot over medium heat. Add a drizzle of olive oil and sauté the onion until translucent, about 5 minutes. Stir in the garlic, ginger, remaining cinnamon, cumin, and coriander; cook for 1 minute until fragrant. 3. Add the rinsed lentils and vegetable broth to the pot. Bring to a boil, then reduce to a simmer and cook for 10 minutes. 4. Transfer the roasted carrots to the pot. Using an immersion blender (or working in batches with a countertop blender), puree the soup until smooth. 5. Stir in the coconut milk and lime juice, and season with salt and pepper to taste. Simmer gently for another 5 minutes to allow flavors to meld. 6. Ladle the soup into bowls, garnish with fresh cilantro leaves, and serve hot. Enjoy!

Concept-guided

Generate 100 themes first, then ask for ten recipes under each theme.

Savory Heather‑Infused Oat Soup with Honey Glaze

Ingredients: - 1 cup steel‑cut oats - 4 cups vegetable broth - 1 tbsp smoked heather leaves, crushed - 1 small onion, diced - 1 carrot, diced - 1 celery stalk, diced - 2 tbsp wild heather honey - 1 tbsp olive oil - Salt and pepper to taste - Fresh thyme for garnish Instructions: 1. Heat olive oil in a pot over medium heat; add onion, carrot, and celery, sauté until softened, about 5 minutes. 2. Stir in crushed smoked heather leaves and toast for 1 minute. 3. Add steel‑cut oats and vegetable broth; bring to a boil, then reduce to a simmer and cook for 20‑25 minutes, stirring occasionally, until oats are tender. 4. Season with salt and pepper; ladle soup into bowls. 5. Drizzle 2 tbsp honey over each serving and garnish with fresh thyme before serving.

Examples from the same 168 recipes per strategy shown below. Scroll inside a card to read the full saved response.

The cards show actual saved outputs. Resampling lets you compare their ingredients and preparation methods, as well as their titles. These examples illustrate what each strategy produced; the measurements below compare the populations as a whole. Some saved outputs are incomplete or contain unusual ingredients, and culinary quality was not evaluated.

Compared to Human Authored Text

To give the generated collections a reference point, we downloaded 168 recipes from Text Only Recipes. We passed every complete recipe text—human and generated—through the same embedding model, text-embedding-3-large. It turns text into a list of 3,072 numbers: a vector that lets us compare recipes by their meaning rather than just their words.

Nearby vectors suggest similar content. To make that space visible, we use principal component analysis, or PCA, which projects the vectors onto two shared axes. Think of it as a flat view of a space with many dimensions: useful for seeing broad patterns, but unable to show every difference.

Nonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Coconut CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Carrot and Coconut SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Carrot & Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Carrot & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ShrimpNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato Buddha BowlNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Carrot & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Citrus Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato StewNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato and Black Bean TacosNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato Buddha BowlNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato and Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Coconut CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spicy Mango Avocado SalsaNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Carrot and Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ShrimpNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Carrot & Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ShrimpNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ShrimpNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Caramel Apple TartNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Carrot & Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Carrot & Chickpea SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spicy Coconut Lime ChickenNonce: Spiced Sweet Potato & Chickpea CurryNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Pumpkin Lentil SoupNonce: Spiced Chickpea and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Spiced Roasted Carrot and Lentil Soup with Coconut MilkPrior titles: Lemon‑Thyme Roasted Cauliflower and Chickpea TabboulehPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Turmeric Shrimp with Coconut‑Lime QuinoaPrior titles: Lemon‑Honey Glazed Chicken with Roasted Garlic BroccoliPrior titles: Spiced Coconut Lime Lentil and Spinach SoupPrior titles: Spiced Coconut Lime Shrimp and Pineapple Fried RicePrior titles: Maple‑Saffron Glazed Tempeh with Roasted Carrot QuinoaPrior titles: Spiced Orange Glazed Tempeh with Coconut RicePrior titles: Smoky Chipotle Lime Chickpea TacosPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Chickpea and Sweet Potato Skillet with Roasted GarlicPrior titles: Spicy Coconut Lime Chicken ThighsPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Parsnip and Chickpea Power BowlPrior titles: Maple‑Miso Glazed Eggplant with Turmeric QuinoaPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Quinoa with Roasted Garlic Chickpeas and LimePrior titles: Spiced Harissa Carrot and Lentil SoupPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Shrimp with Garlic‑Herb CouscousPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Acorn Squash with Lentil PilafPrior titles: Miso‑Brown Butter Ramen with Crispy Tofu and Bok ChoyPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Spiced Roasted Eggplant and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Ginger‑Lime Baked Tofu with Coconut Rice and Roasted Snap PeasPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Sweet Potato and Chickpea Breakfast BurritoPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Tempeh with Roasted Garlic Sweet Potato and KalePrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Carrot and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Cocoa‑Spiced Sweet Potato and Black Bean ChiliPrior titles: Maple‑Miso Glazed Tofu with Roasted Garlic Broccoli and QuinoaPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Chickpea & Sweet Potato SkilletPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Sweet Potato & Chickpea Breakfast HashPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Turmeric Shrimp with Coconut‑Lime RicePrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Carrot and Lentil Pilaf with Citrus VinaigrettePrior titles: Spiced Orange‑Maple Glazed Tempeh with Quinoa and Roasted BroccoliPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Butternut Squash and Farro PilafPrior titles: Spiced Coconut Lime Chickpea and Sweet Potato CurryPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Sweet Potato and Chickpea Buddha BowlPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Sweet Corn and Black Bean SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Beet and Chickpea Power BowlPrior titles: Spiced Orange‑Maple Glazed Tempeh with Quinoa and Roasted BroccoliPrior titles: Ginger‑Lime Coconut Shrimp with Quinoa PilafPrior titles: Herb‑Infused Farro with Roasted Butternut Squash and Toasted PecansPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Coconut Rice with Roasted VeggiesPrior titles: Spiced Apricot Glazed Salmon with Herb QuinoaPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Chickpea and Roasted Beet Salad with Citrus VinaigrettePrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Roasted Eggplant and Farro SaladPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Chickpea and Roasted Tomato PastaPrior titles: Crispy Coconut‑Lime Tempeh with Mango‑Avocado SalsaPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Chickpea and Butternut Squash CouscousPrior titles: Citrus‑Infused Chickpea and Farro Salad with Toasted PistachiosPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Chickpea and Roasted Butternut Squash BowlPrior titles: Spiced Maple‑Glazed Cauliflower and Chickpea TacosPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Tofu with Roasted Brussels Sprouts and Quinoa PilafPrior titles: Herb‑Infused Quinoa with Roasted Garlic Lemon AsparagusPrior titles: Lemon‑Thyme Baked Cod with Herb‑Infused CouscousPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Quinoa Bowl with Roasted EdamamePrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Quinoa with Roasted Garlic and KalePrior titles: Ginger‑Miso Glazed Eggplant with Sesame‑Brown RicePrior titles: Cinnamon‑Lime Roasted Carrot and Chickpea SaladPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Turmeric Tempeh with Coconut Quinoa and Roasted CarrotsPrior titles: Sesame‑Crusted Miso‑Glazed Cod with Coconut Lime RicePrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Glazed Pumpkin and Quinoa Salad with Pomegranate VinaigrettePrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Roasted Brussels Sprouts with Pomegranate Quinoa PilafPrior titles: Herb‑Roasted Chickpea and Sweet Potato Grain BowlPrior titles: Harissa‑Spiced Chickpea and Sweet Potato SkilletPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Roasted Pear and Quinoa Salad with Walnut VinaigrettePrior titles: Roasted Garlic and Herb Chickpea & Sweet Potato TacosPrior titles: Sage‑Infused Pumpkin and Lentil StewPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Pumpkin and Chickpea StewPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Beet and Quinoa Salad with Pomegranate VinaigrettePrior titles: Citrus‑Glazed Tempeh with Herbed Quinoa and Roasted CarrotsPrior titles: Roasted Garlic & Herb Chickpea and Sweet Potato SkilletPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Sweet Potato & Black Bean Breakfast TacosPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Spiced Roasted Cauliflower and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Sweet Potato and Kale TabboulehPrior titles: Maple‑Miso Glazed Cod with Roasted Brussels Sprouts and QuinoaPrior titles: Harissa‑Spiced Roasted Eggplant and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Chickpea and Sweet Potato BakePrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Cauliflower and Chickpea Quinoa PilafPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Sweet Potato and Lentil SoupPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Carrot and Lentil PilafPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Coconut Lime Chickpea and Spinach StewPrior titles: Spiced Harissa Sweet Potato and Black Bean SkilletPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Lime Roasted Cauliflower and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Sesame‑Ginger Tempeh with Coconut‑Lime Rice and Charred BroccoliPrior titles: Honey‑Lime Roasted Cauliflower and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Pumpkin and Chickpea StewPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Farro Salad with Roasted Chickpeas and PomegranatePrior titles: Spiced Maple‑Glazed Eggplant and Quinoa BowlPrior titles: Herb‑Crusted Tofu with Lemon‑Garlic Quinoa and Roasted AsparagusPrior titles: Spiced Orange‑Glazed Tofu with Coconut QuinoaPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Carrot and Lentil Soup with Coconut MilkPrior titles: Sesame‑Lime Glazed Tempeh with Turmeric QuinoaPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Sweet Potato and Black Bean SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Beet and Lentil SoupPrior titles: Maple‑Saffron Glazed Tempeh with Roasted Carrot QuinoaPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Quinoa‑Stuffed Acorn SquashPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Shrimp with Garlic‑Herb QuinoaPrior titles: Spiced Orange‑Glazed Cauliflower and Chickpea TacosPrior titles: Sage‑Infused Roasted Carrot and Lentil Soup with Coconut MilkPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Lime Roasted Cauliflower and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Sweet Potato and Black Bean SaladPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Tofu and Roasted Sweet Potato Buddha BowlPrior titles: Spiced Maple‑Glazed Pumpkin and Quinoa Salad with Pomegranate VinaigrettePrior titles: Roasted Garlic and Lime Quinoa with Pan‑Seared Miso TofuPrior titles: Sage‑Infused Roasted Beet and Barley Salad with Citrus VinaigrettePrior titles: Spiced Coconut Lime Chickpea and Spinach PastaPrior titles: Maple‑Balsamic Roasted Carrots with QuinoaPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Brussels Sprouts and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Turmeric Roasted Carrot and Chickpea SaladPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Eggplant and Lentil TacosPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Turmeric Chickpea and Spinach FlatbreadPrior titles: Roasted Garlic‑Lime Chickpea and Sweet Potato Buddha BowlPrior titles: Lemon‑Basil Grilled Portobello with Quinoa‑Pine Nut SaladPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Coconut Lentil and Spinach CurryPrior titles: Roasted Garlic & Herb Farro with Lemon‑Tahini DressingPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Sweet Potato and Chickpea PilafPrior titles: Crispy Pomegranate‑Balsamic Tofu with Herbed CouscousPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Spiced Apple and Chickpea TaginePrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Carrot and Chickpea SaladPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Chickpea and Sweet Potato Gnocchi BakePrior titles: Lemon‑Basil Orzo with Grilled Eggplant and Pine NutsPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Tempeh with Roasted Carrot and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Lime Roasted Carrot and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Crispy Coconut‑Lime Tofu with Pineapple SalsaPrior titles: Spiced Coconut‑Lime Chickpea & Sweet Potato TaginePrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Seitan with Roasted Sweet Potato and KalePrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Carrot and Lentil Salad with Citrus VinaigrettePrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Quinoa Stuffed Portobello MushroomsPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Pumpkin and Chickpea StewPrior titles: Sage‑Roasted Butternut Squash and Lentil SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Beet and Chickpea Salad with Orange VinaigrettePrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Cauliflower and Chickpea CouscousPrior titles: Crispy Coconut‑Lime Shrimp with Mango Avocado SalsaPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Beet and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Spiced Roasted Carrot and Chickpea SoupPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Coconut Quinoa with Roasted Chickpeas and LimePrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Carrot and Chickpea Tagine with ApricotPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Lentil and Spinach StewPrior titles: Turmeric‑Honey Roasted Carrot and Lentil Salad with PomegranatePrior titles: Cinnamon‑Lime Roasted Chickpea and Sweet Potato BowlPrior titles: Garlic‑Lime Roasted Cauliflower Steaks with Herbed CouscousPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Quinoa Stuffed Sweet Potatoes with Roasted ChickpeasPrior titles: Lemon‑Thyme Roasted Carrot and Farro Salad with PomegranatePrior titles: Cinnamon‑Saffron Roasted Carrot and Chickpea Buddha BowlPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Roasted Beet and Chickpea PilafPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Turmeric Chickpea and Kale SoupPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Spiced Roasted Carrot and Lentil Salad with PomegranatePrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Carrot and Lentil Curry with Coconut RicePrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Quinoa with Roasted Garlic Chickpeas and KalePrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Quinoa with Roasted Garlic Chickpeas and SpinachPrior titles: Roasted Garlic and Lemon‑Basil Farro SaladPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Chickpea & Sweet Potato Skillet with Cashew CrunchPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Spiced Carrot and Chickpea TaginePrior titles: Spiced Maple‑Glazed Eggplant and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Carrot and Lentil SoupPrior titles: Saffron‑Infused Coconut Lime Chickpea and Spinach SoupPrior titles: Rosemary‑Lemon Quinoa with Roasted Cauliflower and PomegranatePrior titles: Sage‑Infused Wild Rice and Roasted Butternut Squash SaladPrior titles: Spicy Sesame Ginger Shrimp with Coconut Lime NoodlesPrior titles: Harissa‑Spiced Roasted Eggplant and Lentil BowlPrior titles: Garlic‑Lime Roasted Cauliflower Steaks with Herbed QuinoaPrior titles: Crispy Orange‑Glazed Tempeh with Coconut‑Lime QuinoaPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Roasted Carrot and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Harissa‑Glazed Cauliflower Steaks with Pomegranate QuinoaPrior titles: Maple‑Glazed Sweet Potato and Lentil Tacos with Avocado CremaPrior titles: Garlic‑Lime Roasted Cauliflower Steaks with Quinoa‑Pomegranate SaladPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Maple Roasted Sweet Potato and Black Bean Quinoa BowlPrior titles: Lemon‑Ginger Turmeric Chickpea and Sweet Potato SkilletPrior titles: Coconut‑Lime Turmeric Chickpea & Quinoa Power BowlPrior titles: Cinnamon‑Sage Roasted Acorn Squash and Quinoa SaladPrior titles: Spiced Cardamom Roasted Carrot and Quinoa SaladConcept-guided: Savory Heather‑Infused Oat Soup with Honey GlazeConcept-guided: Baked Snapper in Coconut Rum Custard with Coconut‑Brown Sugar CrustConcept-guided: Photon‑Pickled Veggie MedleyConcept-guided: Red Velvet & Cream Cheese Halo‑Halo TowerConcept-guided: Kitfo Ice Cream (Savory Dessert)Concept-guided: Saffron‑Infused Almond Ma’amoulConcept-guided: Classic Masala Dosa with Coconut ChutneyConcept-guided: Reindeer Pâté on Herb‑Infused CrispbreadConcept-guided: New‑Moon Mini Mooncakes with Matcha‑Jasmine GlazeConcept-guided: Injera Pizza with Berbere Tomato SauceConcept-guided: Polar Night Citrus Ice‑Fish SoupConcept-guided: Honey‑Glazed Eggplant with InjeraConcept-guided: Coffee‑Braised Beef Meatball PhoConcept-guided: Matcha Soba “Risotto” with Sweet Corn and ShisoConcept-guided: Curry‑Infused Tonkotsu Ramen with Fried TofuConcept-guided: Orange‑Infused Churro Sticks with Mexican Chocolate Mole SauceConcept-guided: Birch‑Smoked Salmon Sushi BurritoConcept-guided: Honey‑Glazed Sweet Dabo KoloConcept-guided: Injera with Lentil & Roasted Eggplant Wat, Lemon SqueezeConcept-guided: Eggplant Moussaka with Couscous BaseConcept-guided: Deconstructed Feijoada Rice BowlConcept-guided: Peanut‑Butter Banana Halo‑Halo TowerConcept-guided: Citrus‑Infused Injera SaladConcept-guided: Berbere Chicken Injera RollConcept-guided: Yak Butter Tea Soup with Barley Noodles & Wild MushroomsConcept-guided: Beetroot Puri with Coconut‑Mint WaterConcept-guided: Cold Jungle Herb Curry SaladConcept-guided: Harissa Lamb Kebabs Tagine with Chickpeas and Dried FruitConcept-guided: Vegan Pistachio Baklava with Coconut Butter and Rose SyrupConcept-guided: Classic Black Clam CevicheConcept-guided: Mushroom Katsu Bento BoxConcept-guided: Quinoa & Methi (Fenugreek) Dosa with Coconut‑Coriander ChutneyConcept-guided: Spicy Gochujang Lotus Root PancakeConcept-guided: Spicy Chili‑Lime Mango Sticky RiceConcept-guided: Gochujang‑Glazed Tofu RamenConcept-guided: Harissa‑Spiced Lamb Kebabs with Mint Yogurt SauceConcept-guided: Harissa Lamb Kebabs with Pomegranate Molasses Glaze and Walnut SaladConcept-guided: Spiced Egg Bhurji Pani PuriConcept-guided: Matcha Soba “Buddha Bowl” with Roasted Sweet Potato and Miso‑Tahini DressingConcept-guided: Classic Shrimp, Sweet Potato & Shiso TempuraConcept-guided: Vegan “Tonkotsu” Ramen (Mushroom‑Bone Broth)Concept-guided: Charred Eggplant Bánh Mì with Hoisin GlazeConcept-guided: Mustard Shrimp on Toasted KnäckebrödConcept-guided: Mole Turkey Pizza with Oaxaca CheeseConcept-guided: Egg‑Yolk‑Rich Tonkotsu Ramen with Pickled GingerConcept-guided: Tempura Salad with Shiso‑Lime VinaigretteConcept-guided: Spicy Açaí Grasshopper TartareConcept-guided: Pickled Cabbage & Hákarl SlawConcept-guided: Classic Crispy Lechon KawaliConcept-guided: Coffee‑Infused Beef Pho with Fried TofuConcept-guided: Mango Sticky Rice Ice Cream SundaeConcept-guided: Starlight Sashimi StackConcept-guided: Lotus Root Pancake with Scallion‑Tofu FillingConcept-guided: Seaweed‑Wrapped Bánh Xèo with Fish FilletConcept-guided: Kimchi & Eggplant Bibimbap with Doenjang GlazeConcept-guided: Grilled Lemongrass Pork Bánh MìConcept-guided: Falafel Burger with Pickled Red Onions and Tahini MayoConcept-guided: Hákarl‑Marinated Mushroom SkewersConcept-guided: Beef Bulgogi Bibimbap with Fermented Soybean PasteConcept-guided: Sweet‑Potato & Kale Paella ValencianaConcept-guided: Mini Pistachio Baklava CupsConcept-guided: Savory Spinach & Feta Injera CrepeConcept-guided: Spiced Eggplant & Walnut Stuffed PitaConcept-guided: Gochujang Tofu Skewers with Sesame‑Soy DrizzleConcept-guided: Grilled Lemongrass Chicken Bánh Mì with AvocadoConcept-guided: Green Curry Noodle Bowl with Bamboo Shoots and Pickled VegetablesConcept-guided: Sand‑Encased Lamb Shank with Barley & Dried Apricot PilafConcept-guided: Tempura Salad with Sesame‑Ginger DressingConcept-guided: Midnight Lantern Seaweed RisottoConcept-guided: Ratatouille Preserves (Jam)Concept-guided: Mushroom‑Truffle Risotto Arancini with Beet‑Infused AioliConcept-guided: Mango Sticky Rice Pancakes with Mango CoulisConcept-guided: Harira with Coconut Milk and LimeConcept-guided: Pork Belly Green Curry with Bamboo Shoots and Thai BasilConcept-guided: Mango Sticky Rice Pancake StackConcept-guided: Almond‑Lemon Tartlets with Warm Mint‑Ginger TeaConcept-guided: Cardamom‑Orange Ethiopian Coffee CakeConcept-guided: Frozen Mushroom & Ice‑Fish BouillonConcept-guided: Piranha Ceviche with Fermented Banana Leaf WrapConcept-guided: Grilled Salmon Poke Bowl with PineappleConcept-guided: Gluten‑Free Teff Dabo KoloConcept-guided: Grilled Piranha Ceviche Salad with Pineapple VinaigretteConcept-guided: Cold Yak Butter Tea Cocktail with Barley Crisp GarnishConcept-guided: Sunlit Kelp Noodle SoupConcept-guided: Edelweiss Fondue Pizza on Alpine FlatbreadConcept-guided: Kurobuta Katsu with Pickled Daikon & Soy ReductionConcept-guided: Churro “Bombs” (Filled Doughnuts) with Peanut‑Butter Chocolate DipConcept-guided: Smoked Reindeer & Cloudberry Ice CreamConcept-guided: Mango‑Coconut Halo‑Halo TowerConcept-guided: Viking Smoked Reindeer & Cloudberry SoupConcept-guided: Mushroom & Seaweed Bibimbap with Doenjang‑Miso SauceConcept-guided: Berry‑Cheesecake PatbingsuConcept-guided: Lotus Root Pancake with Sweet Plum SauceConcept-guided: Baked Gochujang‑Glazed Tofu Skewers with Sesame SeedsConcept-guided: Cuy with Pisco‑Maple Glaze and Roasted CornConcept-guided: Lechon Kawali Sandwich with Liver PâtéConcept-guided: Gluten‑Free Chickpea Bánh XèoConcept-guided: Midnight Sun Ice‑Fish TerrineConcept-guided: Vegan Acarajé with Tofu Vatapá & Roasted Okra CaruruConcept-guided: First‑Quarter Mooncake with Spiced OrangeConcept-guided: Holographic Wasabi FoamConcept-guided: Jungle Curry‑Stewed Tofu with River WatercressConcept-guided: Jungle Curry‑Marinated Grilled River EelConcept-guided: Turnip‑Mint Barley Dumplings in Spicy Tomato Yak Butter BrothConcept-guided: Açai Pine Nut Parfait with Guaraná DrizzleConcept-guided: Tofu‑Infused Kimchi PancakeConcept-guided: Trout‑Infused Rye Bread Pizza with Caramelized ShallotsConcept-guided: Snapper Coconut Rum Ceviche with AvocadoConcept-guided: Coffee‑Spiced Dabo KoloConcept-guided: Yak Butter Tea Ice Cream with Barley CrumbleConcept-guided: Classic Berbere Dabo KoloConcept-guided: Vegan Gulab Jamun (Using Chickpea Flour)Concept-guided: Kimchi‑Spiced Okonomiyaki with Pork BellyConcept-guided: Quinoa‑Lentil Dosa with Coconut‑Peanut ChutneyConcept-guided: Ratatouille Pasta al FornoConcept-guided: Jerk Chicken Lettuce Wraps with Coconut Lime DrizzleConcept-guided: Saffron‑Rose Gulab JamunConcept-guided: Paneer & Spinach Dosa with Coconut‑Coriander ChutneyConcept-guided: Neon‑Infused Ramen with Laser‑Charred EggConcept-guided: Viking Reindeer & Cloudberry PilafConcept-guided: Hákarl & Pickled Cabbage Sushi RollsConcept-guided: Jerk Chicken Pizza with Mango ChutneyConcept-guided: Lechon Kawali Tacos with Mango SalsaConcept-guided: Full‑Moon Celebration Mooncake with Dark Chocolate GanacheConcept-guided: Mushroom‑Tofu Bibimbap with Doenjang‑Sesame SauceConcept-guided: Fig & Olive Relish with Grilled HalloumiConcept-guided: Falafel Pizza with Spiced Tahini DrizzleConcept-guided: Honey‑Glazed Almond ChebakiaConcept-guided: Hákarl & Rye Cracker BitesConcept-guided: Cloudberry‑Infused Reindeer FlatbreadConcept-guided: Kalua Pork & Poi Stuffed Sweet PeppersConcept-guided: Mole Turkey Enchiladas Verde (Fusion)Concept-guided: Mushroom Katsu DonburiConcept-guided: Harissa‑Spiced Charred Couscous with Seven VegConcept-guided: Moroccan Seven‑Vegetable Couscous (Classic)Concept-guided: Coffee‑Butter Molasses RollsConcept-guided: Lavender & Honey Crème Brûlée with Orange ZestConcept-guided: Vanilla‑Infused Coffee Milkshake with Sweet Bread CrumbsConcept-guided: Quantum‑Layered Tomato Terrine SoupConcept-guided: Grilled Lamb Chops with Fig‑Ras el Hanout GlazeConcept-guided: Yak Butter Tea‑Marinated Grilled Lamb with Barley FlatbreadConcept-guided: Spicy Miso‑Glazed Kurobuta KatsuConcept-guided: Gochujang Tofu Skewers in Spicy Ramen SoupConcept-guided: Rye Crouton Salad with Smoked Trout, Apple & Horseradish DressingConcept-guided: Saffron & Porcini Truffle RisottoConcept-guided: Fig‑Infused Lamb Stew with Moroccan SpicesConcept-guided: Mole Pork Sliders with Sesame AioliConcept-guided: Wild Mushroom & Truffle RisottoConcept-guided: Rye Crust Quiche with Smoked Trout, Spinach & Æbleskiver SauceConcept-guided: Sweet Causa Dessert with Quinoa CrumbleConcept-guided: Mini Bánh Xèo Sliders for AppetizersConcept-guided: Gochujang‑Glazed Tofu Fried RiceConcept-guided: Harissa Lamb Kebabs with Harissa‑Infused Olive Oil Drizzle and Grilled HalloumiConcept-guided: Octopus & Fava Bean Ceviche with Olive Oil & OreganoConcept-guided: Mushroom‑Truffle Risotto Pizza with Beet‑Glazed OnionsConcept-guided: Chimichurri Lamb Kebabs with Herb‑Infused Potato SaladConcept-guided: Cuy Ceviche with Coconut Milk and Aji AmarilloConcept-guided: Cactus‑Infused Quinoa SoupConcept-guided: Green Curry Soup with Bamboo Shoots and LemongrassConcept-guided: Injera Breakfast PizzaConcept-guided: Savory Quinoa‑Date Cactus Flatbread with Yogurt DrizzleConcept-guided: Coconut Vinegar Adobo Glaze for Grilled SkewersConcept-guided: Hákarl & Seaweed CrackersConcept-guided: Fig & Lamb Pizza with Moroccan Spice RimConcept-guided: Reindeer Blood Sausage with Cloudberry SauceConcept-guided: Mushroom & Spinach Ayib Wat with InjeraConcept-guided: Causa con Panceta Ahumada y Mayo de Cilantro‑LimaConcept-guided: Rye Bread “Nachos” with Smoked Trout, Roasted Red Pepper & Avocado CremaHuman: Almond Meal Chicken FingersHuman: Almond-Crusted Salmon BitesHuman: Amish Breakfast CasseroleHuman: Apple PieHuman: Baked SalmonHuman: Baked ZitiHuman: BaklavaHuman: Banana BreadHuman: Banana Nut MuffinsHuman: Barbecue SauceHuman: Beef StewHuman: Beef Stir-FryHuman: Beef WellingtonHuman: Blueberry Cheesecake Breakfast BarsHuman: Blueberry Crumble BarsHuman: Blueberry MuffinsHuman: Blueberry ToppingHuman: Caesar SaladHuman: Caramel Apple Pie EnchiladasHuman: Caramel-Pecan Cheesecake PieHuman: Carrot Cake CupcakesHuman: Cheeseburger SoupHuman: Chicken AlfredoHuman: Chicken And DumplingsHuman: Chicken Cordon BleuHuman: Chicken CurryHuman: Chicken EnchiladasHuman: Chicken FajitasHuman: Chicken Fried SteakHuman: Chicken KatsuHuman: Chicken Noodle CasseroleHuman: Chicken Noodle SoupHuman: Chicken ParmesanHuman: Chicken Pot PieHuman: Chicken SoupHuman: Chicken TendersHuman: Chicken tortilla soupHuman: Chopped LiverHuman: Cinnamon Raisin Coffee CakeHuman: Clam DipHuman: Classic MeatloafHuman: Cole Slaw Kfc StyleHuman: Corn Dip Fritos ScoopsHuman: Corn Souffle CasseroleHuman: Cornbread-Topped Chili CasseroleHuman: Corned beef and cabbageHuman: Cottage Cheese PancakesHuman: Crab BisqueHuman: Crab CakesHuman: Crab LegsHuman: Cream Cheese FrostingHuman: Creamy Grape SaladHuman: Creamy Mushroom Sausage PastaHuman: CroutonsHuman: Dutch BabiesHuman: Dutch Baby pancakeHuman: Easy Stuffed SausageHuman: EnchiladasHuman: FalafelHuman: Farmers CasseroleHuman: Fish And ChipsHuman: Fish TacosHuman: French Salad DressingHuman: French ToastHuman: Fried CalamariHuman: Fried FishHuman: Fried RiceHuman: Fruit SaladHuman: Ginger CookiesHuman: Ginger-Lime Key Lime Pie CookiesHuman: Goulash With V8Human: Grandma Sanborns Ginger Bread PeopleHuman: Green Bean CasseroleHuman: Green JuiceHuman: Grilled Huli Huli ChickenHuman: Grilled SalmonHuman: GumboHuman: GyrosHuman: Holiday BrisketHuman: Homemade Alfredo SauceHuman: Homemade BiscuitsHuman: Huevos RancherosHuman: Hungarian stuffed bell peppersHuman: Instant Pot ChiliHuman: Instant Pot Hot JambalayaHuman: Instant Pot Tikka MasalaHuman: Instant Pot Tikka Masala PaneerHuman: Kale SaladHuman: Key Lime PieHuman: Kombucha First FermentHuman: Krispy Kale RiceHuman: LasagnaHuman: Latkes Potato PancakesHuman: Lemon Orzo ChickenHuman: Lentil SoupHuman: Linguine With Red Clam SauceHuman: Lobster Mac And CheeseHuman: Macaroni ColeslawHuman: Maccaroni SaladHuman: MargaritasHuman: Mashed CauliflowerHuman: Mashed PotatoesHuman: Meatball SlidersHuman: Meatball SubsHuman: Meatloaf 4 Hour BodyHuman: Mexican Street Corn SaladHuman: Monster MashHuman: Mushroom SoupHuman: Naan PizzaHuman: No Bake CheesecakeHuman: No Bake CookiesHuman: Oatmeal CookiesHuman: Orange ChickenHuman: Orange JuliusHuman: Oven Roasted PotatoesHuman: Overnight OatsHuman: Pad ThaiHuman: PancakesHuman: Pasta CarbonaraHuman: Peanut Butter CookiesHuman: Pecan PieHuman: Philly Cheese Steak SandwichHuman: Pizza DoughHuman: Pizza SauceHuman: PokeHuman: Pork ChopsHuman: Pot RoastHuman: Potato LyonnaiseHuman: Potato SaladHuman: Pulled Pork SandwichesHuman: QuesadillasHuman: RataouilleHuman: Red Beans And RiceHuman: Rhubarb Custard BarsHuman: RibeezHuman: RisottoHuman: Roast beefHuman: Roasted Chicken BreastsHuman: Roasted TurkeyHuman: Sausage RisottoHuman: Sauteed Spinach And TomatoesHuman: Scalloped PotatoesHuman: ScallopsHuman: Sexy Time SteakHuman: Shepard's pieHuman: Shiitake RisottoHuman: Shrim ScampiHuman: Sloppy JoesHuman: Soft Molasses CookiesHuman: Sour Cream CakeHuman: Sourdough StarterHuman: Spaghetti BologneseHuman: Spaghetti and meatballsHuman: Stir-Fried VegetablesHuman: Stuffed peppersHuman: Sushi Rolls (Homemade)Human: Tart Strawberry Rhubarb PieHuman: Tartar sauce for halibut (Jamie’s)Human: Tater Tot CasseroleHuman: Thanksgiving Turkey AlternateHuman: Thanksgiving Turkey JoannasHuman: Tomato Vodka SauceHuman: Tri TipHuman: Tuna CasseroleHuman: Turkey MeatloafHuman: Vegetable SoupHuman: Zucchini BreadHuman: Zucchini Muffins
Hover over a point to see its title.

Hover over a point to view the recipe here. Click to pin.

The nonce recipes form a much tighter pattern. Prior titles spread out more, while concept-guided recipes extend farther into the area occupied by the human collection. This suggests that choosing themes first helps the model explore a broader range of recipe ideas.

The full-dimensional coverage measurement supports that interpretation. We drew a neighborhood around each human recipe using its fifth-nearest human neighbor, then checked whether each strategy put at least one recipe inside. Concept-guided prompting reached 79 of 168 neighborhoods (47.0%), compared with 59 (35.1%) for prior titles and 22 (13.1%) for nonce. These counts use all 1,000 generated recipes per strategy, not just the displayed sample. Concept guidance reaches more of this reference collection, though still less than half of its neighborhoods.

Conclusions

Concept-guided prompting gives a language model different places to begin. In this experiment, that small change produced more internal variation, closer average alignment with the human reference, and broader coverage than either baseline. It did so by organizing generation around themes, without an iterative process that scored and improved the recipes.

For automated research, the next step is to test whether this broader pool leads to better candidates after evaluation. Program search and feature engineering are promising settings, but this recipe study does not yet establish those benefits. The results also come from one saved comparison, with different request structures and response limits across strategies. Independent runs and direct quality evaluation will be needed to understand how far the approach generalizes.

The paper describes the full analysis and its limitations. The code and saved research artifacts make the experiment available for inspection.